‘Embarrassed’ Tafoya Recalls Prior Minnesota Campaign Gaffes and Goofs

Share article

Michele Tafoya’s remarks about Minnesota recall a bipartisan history of campaign blunders, from the two Rudys to Mike Hatch and Scott Jensen.

One of the latest brouhahas during the current midterm election campaign season is the airing of an advertisement by Ohio Republican gubernatorial candidate Vivek Ramaswamy featuring the estranged mother of his Democratic opponent, Amy Acton, calling her a “liar.”

The ad attacks Acton’s account of her childhood hardships. It does not specifically mention sexual abuse, although her mother previously disputed Acton’s account of being sexually abused by her stepfather. Contemporaneous records support key elements of Acton’s account, including the criminal charges brought against him.

The ad stirred a flurry of fury, including criticism from some of Ramaswamy’s Republican colleagues. President Trump stepped in and wholeheartedly supported it, even as he claimed Ramaswamy had not been involved in making it. Ramaswamy has taken responsibility for the ad. A number of pundits and other observers have speculated that it will backfire and help Acton, a former director of the Ohio Department of Health, in the closely contested race.

The imbroglio recalls political remarks, gaffes and goofs that have backfired throughout the political thicket here in the Twin Cities and Greater Minnesota.

Michele Tafoya speaks at Turning Point USA’s Young Women’s Leadership Summit in Grapevine, Texas, on June 10, 2023. Photo: Gage Skidmore, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0.

One of the most recent controversies involves GOP senatorial hopeful Michele Tafoya, coming off the sidelines and getting onto the political field. During this year’s campaign, she denied ever saying she was embarrassed to be from Minnesota. But CNN unearthed a deleted 2023 social media post in which she wrote:

“I’m embarrassed to say I live in Minnesota.”

The controversy was one of a number of fumbles by the overmatched but telegenic candidate whose main qualification seems to be her decade-long gig as a television football sideline commentator.

The denigration of the state she seeks to represent in the nation’s capital attracted criticism, put her on the defensive in her campaign against DFL-endorsed Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan and raised questions about whether the former Sunday night TV personality is ready for prime time.

It also recalled other gaffes by Minnesota candidates from both parties that helped doom their campaigns.

Rude Rudys

The two Rudys who dominated the Minnesota political scene for most of the 1980s suffered setbacks when the next decade began, aided by boorish campaign remarks.

Gov. Rudy Perpich delivers his State of the State address in the Minnesota House chamber in 1983. Photo: Mark Nelson / Minnesota Digital Library, via Wikimedia Commons.

Gov. Rudy Perpich, the first governor from the Iron Range, was aiming for an unprecedented third four-year term in 1990 when he chose to read from and display the divorce papers of his GOP opponent, Jon Grunseth, on the campaign stump. The bizarre tactic reflected desperation and contributed to his defeat by a last-minute substitute, Arne Carlson.

Carlson replaced Grunseth, who withdrew after two sex-related scandals emerged in the waning days of the campaign.

Meanwhile, during the same election cycle, the GOP’s Rudy, Sen. Boschwitz, allowed his campaign apparatus to play the religion card near the end of his race against little-known DFL upstart Paul Wellstone, who was traipsing around the state in a battered old green school bus.

A letter circulated by Boschwitz supporters to members of the Jewish community questioned Wellstone’s Jewish commitments, noting that he had married a non-Jewish woman, Sheila, and that their children had been raised as non-Jews.

The derogation turned into a Boschwitz boomerang, condemned by many Jews and leaders of other faiths for injecting religiosity into the campaign. It also might have cost him support among biased voters who had not realized that Boschwitz, whose family escaped pre-World War II Nazi Germany, was Jewish and therefore eschewed voting for him.

In any event, it contributed to his defeat as he, like the governor, sought a third elected term.

Gun Gaffe

Four years later, a brouhaha over gun regulations shot down the gubernatorial campaign of former Minneapolis Police Chief Tony Bouza.

Tony Bouza during his tenure as Minneapolis police chief. Source: Minneapolis Police Department

Debating his DFL primary foe, state Sen. John Marty of Roseville, the outspoken cop called for much stricter gun restrictions, including licensing gun owners like vehicle drivers and suggesting that handguns should be confiscated.

In today’s DFL, that stance might be venerated. But at the time, it was anathema to a sizable segment of the party, especially in rural areas, on the Iron Range and in the Northland, which were still Democratic strongholds. The proposal spawned a brouhaha that toppled Bouza from the top of the polls.

Having shot himself in the foot, or another part of his lanky anatomy, Bouza was handily defeated by Marty, who went on to lose by nearly a 2-to-1 margin to incumbent Carlson.

Mike’s Meltdown

The DFL seemed poised to recapture the governorship in 2006 for the first time since Perpich’s defeat. Attorney General Mike Hatch, who had once unsuccessfully challenged Perpich for the DFL nomination, headed into the campaign’s final week leading or tied with Republican incumbent Tim Pawlenty in the polls.

Mike Hatch appears on stage to accept his party’s endorsement on June 10, 2006. Source: MPR Photo/Mark Zdechlik

But the feisty AG, reputed to have a volatile temperament, displayed it in an exchange with Forum Communications reporter Scott Wente. The reporter said Hatch called him a “Republican whore”; Hatch maintained that he had said “Republican hack.”

The disputed exchange followed an embarrassing interview aired by KSTP-TV in which Hatch’s running mate, Judi Dutcher, a former Republican, displayed a dumbfounding lack of familiarity with E-85 ethanol fuel. Wente had questioned Hatch about Dutcher’s knowledge of ethanol and her availability for an interview.

Hatch also berated KSTP’s Hubbard family ownership.

His meltdown contributed to his narrow defeat in a year of a Democratic electoral wave locally and nationally, bringing the Duluthian’s promising political career to a thudding end.

Abortion Ambivalence

Then there was GOP gubernatorial candidate Dr. Scott Jensen, who, running against incumbent Tim Walz four years ago, jump-started his campaign by declaring that he “would try to ban abortion.” He later expressed regret about the position and criticized the party’s endorsement process for its emphasis on abortion and guns.

Republican gubernatorial candidate Scott Jensen speaks with a supporter at the Minnesota State Fair on Sept. 1, 2022. Photo: Chad Davis, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.

The stance helped him obtain the party’s nomination. But it did not play well among the broader electorate, and Jensen spent the next two trimesters of the campaign trying to walk it back.

In doing so, he thrashed around with contradictory position statements that reflected ambivalence or, worse yet, disingenuousness regarding reproductive rights. That vacillation contributed to his defeat just months after the Supreme Court eradicated the federal constitutional right to abortion in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization.

But Jensen is back, having obtained his party’s nomination for state auditor this year, a position that does not deal with reproductive rights unless he manages to stumble into that thicket.

All of these campaign missteps, from the rudeness of the two Rudys to Bouza’s bluster, Hatch’s hissy fit and Jensen’s vacillations, helped pave the way to electoral defeats for the five candidates.

There certainly are other devastating verbal gaffes by office seekers, like John Kerry’s memorable “I actually did vote for the $87 billion before I voted against it,” referring to funding for Iraq and Afghanistan in 2004, and Hillary Clinton’s unforgettable “basket of deplorables” 12 years later, directed at half of Donald Trump’s supporters.

It remains to be seen whether Tafoya can recover from her fumble or will be thrust back to the sidelines by the voters.

About the Author

Marshall H. Tanick
Marshall H. Tanick
Marshall H. Tanick is a Twin Cities Constitutional and employment law attorney and historian.

7 COMMENTS

  1. Marshall, Thanks for the trip down memory lane. In ’08, a friend of mine who was a few cycles ahead of me in getting heavily involved in local campaigns, taught me a way to analyze any MN district, precinct by precinct. His idea was that you could get a rather good sense of both how many rock-solid DFL votes there were in a precinct, and how many could be persuaded to vote for a DFLer via exemplary campaigning – the “floor” and the “ceiling”, if you will – simply by noting the number of votes in that precinct in ’06 for Hatch for Governor, and for Amy Klobuchar for Senate, respectively. He explained that he had learned it several cycles earlier in the form of looking at every single partisan-labelled office on the ballot in the decade, and noting the low and the high, but that “because of ’06, you only have to look at Mike and Amy when you do it for this year! They are always the ‘low’ and the ‘high’!” I did this analysis that year for a number of DFL State Leg. candidates, and it really helped in setting our target vote numbers, identifying good precincts and tough ones, etc. I did it again, in ’10 for several candidates, after realizing that Hatch’06 and Klobuchar’06 were STILL the decade-long low and high for almost any precinct, even after adding in the ’08 results… Alas, redistricting turned doing this kind of analysis back into complicated, hard work again by ’12…

  2. Michelle Tafoya may lack experience in the political arena as do most people when they run for office the first time. That doesn’t mean she’s not smart enough to be a senator as evidenced by the many clowns now serving in the senate. Peggy Flanagan has more experience? Sure she does. On her watch with Tim she let the the state treasury be looted by her Somali friends. I would rather have Tafoyas lack of experience than the very poor experience we have had with Peggy Flanagan as our senator. What a colossal mistake our state will be making if she’s elected

Become a Minneapolis Times Member

Become a member of the Minneapolis Times community and be in the know for all things Minneapolis.

Related articles

Minnesota’s Workforce Grants Need Shop-Floor Proof, Not Just Certificates

Publicly funded training should deliver lasting benefits for workers and employers. A few practical measures could show whether...

Part 1: Minnesota Teacher Training: What is Experience in a Broken System?

Some undergraduate and graduate Schools of Education in the Twin Cities have become institutional dinosaurs, led by people...

Two New Federal Lawsuits Could Hit Targets Here

Challenges to Minnesota’s firearm purchase restrictions and St. Paul’s rules for federal officers could find receptive ground in...

Vikings Get Ready for Bills’ MVP Allen, Whose Career Took Off Here

Eight years after earning his first NFL victory in Minneapolis, Josh Allen returns with an MVP award and...