Flock Cameras: Protecting Both Our Streets and Our Rights

Share article

Minnesota should keep a valuable police tool—and insist on strict limits, local control and serious penalties for surveillance abuse.

Communities across Minnesota are rightfully concerned about the constitutional dilemmas posed by Flock cameras. These cameras give police a powerful investigative tool, but they can also create enormous amounts of data about people who have done absolutely nothing wrong. So, ban them altogether? No. Let’s find a balance. Minnesota can protect privacy without stripping law enforcement of a highly effective tool.

The evidence that these cameras make us safer is difficult to dispute. Edina police report 75 arrests related to Flock alerts, along with 34 stolen vehicles recovered, six illegally possessed firearms recovered and one missing person located. These are real outcomes from potentially lifesaving investigations, outcomes that may have taken much longer, or may not have happened at all, without Flock cameras.

But like any surveillance tool, these powerful license plate readers must operate within constitutional limits. The Fourth Amendment exists to protect Americans against unreasonable government searches. Effectiveness does not give government a blank check.

Consider the scale of this technology, because it matters.

A police officer seeing my license plate as I drive through an intersection is one thing. The government having a searchable history of where my vehicle has traveled is another. What once would have required significant time and investigative effort can now be accessed with just a few clicks.

Minnesota courts have grappled with a similar privacy question recently. In State v. Contreras-Sanchez, the court considered law enforcement’s access to Google location data obtained through a geofence warrant. The court recognized a reasonable expectation of privacy in the Google location data at issue and held that government access to it constituted a search under the Minnesota Constitution.

Flock data presents a different legal question because the cameras record vehicles traveling on public roads. That raises a valid question though: If the government can’t freely access a history of where my phone has been, why should it be able to freely access a history of where my vehicle has been?

Fortunately, Minnesota law already places limits on how police can use information collected by license plate readers. Searches must be connected to legitimate law-enforcement purposes and active criminal investigations, and agencies must keep records of who accesses the data and why. Using the technology to actively track someone under investigation generally requires a warrant.

However, rules only work when access is actually controlled. Fridley discovered that outside agencies had searched its Flock network for immigration-related purposes, even though those searches did not align with the city’s policies. Fridley responded by shutting off immigration-related searches and restricting outside access. That is exactly why local control and meaningful oversight should be written into state law.

These protections are essential to protecting the rights of Minnesotans, and they should be strengthened. Ripping the cameras out altogether is not the answer. These cameras can save lives and make our streets safer without sacrificing our constitutional rights.

To ensure this, local agencies should have control over access to data collected in their communities. Searches should be documented and routinely audited. Data about ordinary Minnesotans should not be retained longer than necessary. Outside agencies should not have unrestricted access. They should have to obtain permission from the local agency or, when appropriate, get a warrant.

Most importantly, the penalty for abuse should be serious.

Under Minnesota’s Government Data Practices Act, a person who willfully violates Chapter 13 or knowingly obtains protected data without authorization can face a misdemeanor.

A misdemeanor is not enough for deliberate surveillance abuse.

If an official knowingly uses this surveillance technology to track, for example, an ex-partner, political opponent, neighbor or anyone else for a personal or illegitimate purpose, they should face serious consequences. That is not a minor offense. The constitutional rights of Minnesotans must be taken seriously.

We as Minnesotans want and need effective law enforcement, and Flock cameras can help provide it, but this should not be a choice between privacy and effective policing.

A tool that has proven its value in helping police locate missing people, recover illegal firearms and apprehend suspects is worth preserving, of course, with thoughtful safeguards in place to protect the rights of Minnesotans. Balancing public safety with individual liberty is not a new challenge.

These cameras make us safer. Don’t ban them. Regulate them.

About the Author

AJ Gubash
AJ Gubash
AJ Gubash is a Minnesota paralegal working in nonprofit public-interest law, a graduate legal studies student at Hamline University, and a candidate for the Minnesota House of Representatives in District 53A.

1 COMMENT

Become a Minneapolis Times Member

Become a member of the Minneapolis Times community and be in the know for all things Minneapolis.

Related articles

Part 1: Minnesota Teacher Training: What is Experience in a Broken System?

Some undergraduate and graduate Schools of Education in the Twin Cities have become institutional dinosaurs, led by people...

Two New Federal Lawsuits Could Hit Targets Here

Challenges to Minnesota’s firearm purchase restrictions and St. Paul’s rules for federal officers could find receptive ground in...

Vikings Get Ready for Bills’ MVP Allen, Whose Career Took Off Here

Eight years after earning his first NFL victory in Minneapolis, Josh Allen returns with an MVP award and...

Minneapolis Should Leave the Door Open to Data Centers

Council Member Elizabeth Shaffer is right: responsible regulation should leave a realistic opportunity for investment. The Planning Commission’s...