Socrates Has Some Questions for the City Council

Share article

Before requiring drivers in driverless cars, Minneapolis council members might explain their reasoning on jobs, safety and consumer choice.

Socrates, like most philosophers over the millennia, spent his life searching for truth. He developed a set of methods, known by his name to this day. His methods involved vigorously question advocates for any particular proposition. He wasn’t mean-spirited, but he asked, always, what do you think you know? How do you know it? What is your proof? What if your assertion does not withstand contrary evidence?

Out of these and many other questions, Socrates felt truth would emerge.

On Oct. 1 I watched the Minneapolis City Council meeting and its discussion of an ordinance to allow driverless vehicles to operate in the city as long as they had a driver. Imagine my surprise when Socrates took a seat just to my right. (Good thing; I don’t hear out of my left ear.)

After about 15 minutes, though, he said to me, hold my mead, and left. It looked to me like he had no tolerance for what he was hearing. He never returned. Before he left, though, Socrates told me to take notes and ask some questions of the City Council majority as a whole, and of some individual members. He’d have done it better, but here’s my best shot at it.

Some questions for the City Council majority

When did it become the job of local government to protect specific jobs from competition? How did you decide which jobs to protect and which to leave to market forces? For example, did you think about protecting utility meter reader jobs when the task of measuring kilowatt hours and cubic centimeters of gas became largely automated? If not, why not?

If the priority is to protect employment, wouldn’t it be better for the Council majority to abandon its anti-business stance? Wouldn’t that create and save jobs across the city’s entire economy, rather than picking out specific industries?

Several times you spoke about how awful it is that rideshare drivers displaced taxi drivers. Does it strike you as awkward, at least, that you are now trying to protect the very workers who displaced the taxi drivers?

Do you think it’s possible that rideshare platforms have largely displaced taxis, not because of the schemes of plutocrats, but because customers – ordinary people who need to move around cities – decided overwhelmingly that Uber and Lyft offered a better product?

Although the DSA platform advocates social ownership of all major industries and infrastructure – a position you are fully entitled to embrace – do you acknowledge that in the present moment we have a free market economy? One where consumers get to choose what goods and services they prefer?

Do you think prior city councils were mistaken not to protect the jobs of elevator operators in Minneapolis? Or newspaper typesetters? Do you think our city would be better if all of those elevator operators and all those typesetters were still in place?

The Council majority made several assertions, with anecdotes but without data, that automated vehicles are unsafe, and are less safe than vehicles with drivers.  Even though you don’t like data, do you occasionally take a look at it? Such as studies that conclude that the vast majority of severe auto collisions are caused by human behavioral error? Or data collected across tens of millions of miles, that showed an 81% reduction in injury-resulting crashes when automated vehicles are compared with human-driver vehicles? Or another study showing 95% fewer crashes causing serious injury or worse over 271 million driverless miles through June 2026? Doesn’t this make you curious, at least, about whether it might be possible to reduce deaths and injuries by encouraging, rather than blocking, further development of autonomous vehicles?

(Special variation of the above questions for CM Stevenson, who told us that the only places in the world that have improved street safety are those that committed to walking, biking and transit. There is, in fact, another place in the world that has greatly improved street safety, through better car design and better DWI enforcement. It’s a place called the United States. From 1984 through 2024 traffic deaths per 100,000 population were reduced 44% through these strategies. Any inclination to temper your rhetoric given this history? Would you have opposed seat belt, air bag, and .08 DWI laws, because they reduced employment for funeral directors?)

Why do you put development of automated vehicles and continued improvement in public transit in opposition to one another? Can’t we do both?

If we are worried about safety – and we should be concerned about such things as winter weather and school bus signs – wouldn’t it be better public policy to develop performance standards that any and all autonomous vehicle platforms must be able to meet to address these concerns, and then develop regulations accordingly?

The phrase, existential threat to jobs, has been thrown about a lot. Yet the experience of San Francisco, Los Angeles, Atlanta, and elsewhere show automated vehicles have reduced revenue – and thus employment and wages – for rideshare platforms, but the latter still have a much larger share of total rides. Why, then, would we regard the threat to jobs as “existential”?

(Special question for CM Chavez. You seemed to accept that the actual safety record of autonomous vehicles is pretty strong, if not yet perfect. But you expressed great concern that AVs have killed cats. And you are a cat owner. I truly empathize with your concern; one of the worst moments in my life was when my beloved cocker spaniel, Shadow, was killed by a car. This, however, was in 1957, so the car definitely had a driver. Is it your belief that no cats have ever been killed by a car driven by a person? Why do you feel this risk is unique to automated vehicles?)

Well, there was a lot more magical thinking that could be called out and discussed, but this set of questions might be enough. Enough, at least, to give the Council majority a while to come up with the answers, perhaps until October 27, 2027, when the ordinance, if it overcomes the Mayor’s veto, will take effect. Which raises one last question: What’s the point? What worker protections, what safety advances, are we promoting now, when the ordinance doesn’t even become effective for a year? Couldn’t we wait for the city’s own report, and for 2027 legislative action – and then do policy and regulation in light of what we will know then?

Socrates, you can rejoin us now. The mead has lost its chill and crispness by now, though.

About the Author

David J. Therkelsen
David J. Therkelsen
David Therkelsen has been a homeowner in Minneapolis for 50 years, and attentive to city and school affairs for all of that time. Professionally, he headed two American Red Cross field units, and at one time was co-chief of staff to the President of American Red Cross in Washington, DC. Later he was executive director of Crisis Connection, a state-wide mental health counseling agency. Dave held faculty appointments at the University of Minnesota School of Journalism and Mass Communication, and recently co-authored a book about the history of transfusion medicine and blood banking.

6 COMMENTS

  1. At the risk of re-litigating an old issue, and since you brought up taxis, I feel I must mention that the more clear-minded way to think about the dawn of Uber/Lyft and the sunset of taxis was NOT that one set of workers displaced another. It is that we allowed two corporations to enter the taxi business and avoid the regulations that were there to protect all of us – both drivers (income level) and passengers (safety). We did this not by revisiting those regulations in a democratic way and repealing ones we felt as a people we could do without. Rather, we allowed very crafty businesspeople at those two companies to claim that what they were doing was fundamentally *not* providing taxi service, and was thus not subject to the pre-existing regulations, and then we chose not to regulate, in most meaningful ways, what they *were* doing. This is not an indictment of Minneapolis, or the Twin Cities Metro, or MN. This happened all around the country, and it still perplexes me. What is it about our American regulatory environment that so encourages us to throw it all aside at the appearance of the first slick operator(s) who claim to have found an exploitable loophole? …especially, when we don’t even meaningfully debate the possibility of *just closing the loophole* that they claim to have found…?

  2. And what about the thousands of other independent contractor drivers? Any delivery driver driving their own vehicle has massive expenses. I know because I was one for 30 years with various companies. The costs over that period increased x10. One courier company illegally passed their required insurance costs onto the drivers. That’s when I quit. The Council’s micromanaging piecemeal approach amounts to drops in the bucket and is little more than virtue signaling. And their war on cars with forced bike lanes and curb build-outs does the opposite of reducing greenhouse gas emissions. How is that consistent with socialism or help more than a tiny percentage of our population? These issues expose their glaring lack of understanding of reality outside their academic bubble of privilege and how everything affects everything else.

  3. After my last experience with Uber, I have way mo’ trust in Waymo.

    Both the city council and park board would benefit from philosophy classes. I’ve been noticing a significant lack in ability to think critically.

    Good article, David.

Become a Minneapolis Times Member

Become a member of the Minneapolis Times community and be in the know for all things Minneapolis.

Related articles

Minnesota’s Workforce Grants Need Shop-Floor Proof, Not Just Certificates

Publicly funded training should deliver lasting benefits for workers and employers. A few practical measures could show whether...

Part 1: Minnesota Teacher Training: What is Experience in a Broken System?

Some undergraduate and graduate Schools of Education in the Twin Cities have become institutional dinosaurs, led by people...

Two New Federal Lawsuits Could Hit Targets Here

Challenges to Minnesota’s firearm purchase restrictions and St. Paul’s rules for federal officers could find receptive ground in...

Vikings Get Ready for Bills’ MVP Allen, Whose Career Took Off Here

Eight years after earning his first NFL victory in Minneapolis, Josh Allen returns with an MVP award and...