The Backfire: Why Flawed ICE Arrests Are Leading to Dismissed Drug Cases

Share article

If you don’t live in the 7th Ward you might have missed this latest and greatest horror of the ICE occupation, as described in Council Member Elizabeth Shaffer’s newsletter. Some of it has been reported elsewhere, but not stated as baldly.

It is becoming apparent that even in its own most fundamental terms – that Operation Metro Surge was intended to rid Minneapolis of the “worst of the worst” – the enterprise not only failed, but actually has turned drug dealers and the like back out on the streets.

Between flawed arrests and lack of enough prosecutors (remember the 14 members who resigned because they will not be party to illegal or unconstitutional actions?) the U.S. Attorney’s Office is beginning to voluntarily dismiss serious drug crime cases.

Thomas Homan has told us that Operation Metro Surge resulted in about 4,000 arrests. Since ICE, Border Patrol and Homeland Security have lied to us about many other things, this might be a lie as well. But we have learned elsewhere that only about 14% of the arrests were of people who had committed violent crimes. Now we’re learning that even some, and perhaps many, of these will be returned to our community because of the flaws and illegalities of the ICE operation.

CM Shaffer also speculates that “next, we may see the fraud cases that (ostensibly) started this whole mess begin to falter” as a consequence of too few prosecutors.

Certainly the greatest outrage of the ICE occupation was the murder of two good people exercising their legal rights under the First, Second and Fourth Amendments. In second place is wholesale denial of Constitutional rights to hundreds of others of our neighbors. But a close third has to be this Alice-in-Wonderland result, that even the claimed original intent of the occupation has not only not been met but things may have been made worse.

If the feds had the integrity to take responsibility for their operational failures, and for their jack-booted trampling on the Constitution, they would provide, at their expense, additional prosecutorial resources over the next six to 12 months so that all the valid cases could be tried.

But they don’t and they won’t.

About the Author

David J. Therkelsen
David J. Therkelsen
David Therkelsen has been a homeowner in Minneapolis for 50 years, and attentive to city and school affairs for all of that time. Professionally, he headed two American Red Cross field units, and at one time was co-chief of staff to the President of American Red Cross in Washington, DC. Later he was executive director of Crisis Connection, a state-wide mental health counseling agency. Dave held faculty appointments at the University of Minnesota School of Journalism and Mass Communication, and recently co-authored a book about the history of transfusion medicine and blood banking.

2 COMMENTS

  1. I am not certain I am understanding your point, but I am pretty sure I agree with you. I don’t think there is “behavioral evidence” that ICE intended to rid Minneapolis of the “worst of the worst.” But that was their own rhetoric. Their actions are indeed more revealing than their words.

  2. Let’s start with a question about an assumption. What behavioral evidence was demonstrated to suggest that Operation Metro Surge was intended to rid Minneapolis of the “worst of the worst”? Actions are more revealing than words.

Become a Minneapolis Times Member

Become a member of the Minneapolis Times community and be in the know for all things Minneapolis.

Related articles

Quatrefoil Library – Minnesota’s Historical LBGTQIA+ Library Celebrates 40th Anniversary

A Discussion with Karen Hogan, Head Librarian, Katie Hagen, Library Manager and Iggy Gehlen, Vice President Founded in 1986,...

Politically Homeless: A Vote Is Not a Home

Voting against the other side can keep you loyal long after you stop feeling represented. An election can leave...

The Scariest House on the Block

Politics is serious business. Political theater is another matter. Have an idea we should draw next? Leave it...

Socrates Has Some Questions for the City Council

Before requiring drivers in driverless cars, Minneapolis council members might explain their reasoning on jobs, safety and consumer...